Eczema and MSG Sensitivity
MSG is a natural building block of proteins and when it’s not attached to protein it enhances the flavour of foods. However, consumption of MSG can cause a vast range of side-effects including eczema symptoms. The first medical reports on the adverse effects of MSG referred to it as “Chinese Restaurant Syndrome”.
According to the American Nutrition Association, at least 25% of the U.S. population have adverse reactions to free glutamic acid, a source of MSG present in many packaged foods. Most people don’t know they’re sensitive to flavour enhancers and children are commonly affected.
Research by Loblay and Swain from the RPA Hospital allergy unit (Sydney, Australia) found that more than 90% of people with eczema are sensitive to food chemicals and 35% have a worsening of eczema symptoms when they eat foods containing the additive MSG. However, all eczema sufferers can benefit from avoiding MSG for a while and here's why:
Why is MSG bad for eczema?
Frequent consumption of MSG reduces stores of glutathione, an important antioxidant enzyme needed for liver detoxification of chemicals. Glutathione also keeps your skin looking young. When glutathione is reduced, Phase II liver detoxification reduces and this increases sensitivity to chemicals which can trigger or worsen eczema symptoms. Your skin can also appear drier and wrinkles increase in aged skin. According to the American Nutrition Association, here are the common signs and symptoms to look for:
TABLE 1:
MSG Sensitivity Symptoms |
|
||
Skin
Eczema, hives or rash Red, blotchy rash around mouth Mouth lesions Temporary tightness or partial paralysis Numbness or tingling of the skin Flushing Burning sensations Extreme dryness of the mouth Facial pressure Premature ageing of skin |
Neurological Moodiness, irritability, Depression Dizziness, light-headedness, loss of balance Disorientation, mental confusion Anxiety, panic attacks Hyperactivity, ADHD, ADD Behavioural problems in children Lethargy, sleepiness, insomnia Sleep disturbances, restlessness Migraine headache Numbness or paralysis Seizures, Sciatica, Slurred speech |
||
Cardiac Arrhythmias Extreme rise or drop in blood pressure Rapid heartbeat (tachycardia) Angina |
Circulatory Flu-like achiness Joint pain Stiffness |
||
Gastrointestinal Diarrhoea Nausea, vomiting Stomach cramps Irritable bowel Bloating |
Respiratory Asthma, Shortness of breath Chest pain, tightness Runny nose, Sneezing |
||
Urological Swelling of prostate Nocturia (excessive need to urinate at night) |
Visual Blurred vision, Difficulty focusing |
MSG and other flavour enhancers are often added to packaged soups, savoury biscuits and chicken salted foods. In the 1990s a new range of flavour enhancers including ribonucleotide and other MSG boosters were introduced, and adverse reactions increased in frequency due to higher intakes. A list of problematic flavour enhancers can be found on TABLE 3, below.
“How do I know if I am sensitive to MSG?”
After eating MSG-rich foods, if you or your child have a worsening of eczema or other symptoms (detailed in Table 1) then you may have MSG sensitivity. However it can be hard to tell as reactions can take 24-48 hours to appear. If you are unsure and want to determine if you are sensitive to it, avoid all MSG-rich products for about 4 weeks then reintroduce MSG food into your diet and see if there is an adverse reaction. If you would like a program to follow, The Eczema Diet can help you with MSG-free recipes and shopping lists.
TABLE 2: Products to Avoid
Sources of natural MSG |
Sources of artificial flavour enhancers (all types) |
fresh tomato tomato ketchup, tomato paste tomato-based pasta sauces tomato juice, vegetable juices fish paste, flavoured tuna soy sauce and tamari soy paste all sauces yeast extracts broccoli mushrooms spinach and silver beet green peas (fresh) grapes, raisins, sultanas plums prunes baked beans miso, tempeh, kombu extract Braggs parmesan and rocquefort cheese hydrolysed vegetable protein protein powders (glutamic acid) alcoholic beverages: port, wine, rum, sherry, brandy and liqueur |
soy sauce, BBQ sauce (all sauces) flavoured chips/crisps and crackers cheese-flavoured snacks and crisps spicy flavoured snacks and crisps rice crackers (even some plain varieties) meat pastes deli meats: i.e. devon, salami, sausages some hams, deli sliced turkey/chicken meat pies, party pies, chicken nuggets seasoned or marinated meats barbequed chicken flavoured noodles chicken-salted chips, chicken salt ranch dressings stock cubes canned and packaged soups, baked beans (ingredient “flavours”) gravies Vegemite, Marmite, Promite, Vegespread many fast foods traditional Chinese cooking Seasonings: Ve-tsin, Accent, Gourmet Powder, Zest, Ajinomoto and Chinese (Source: American Nutrition Association) |
Did you know?
Processed foods, such as rice crackers and some health food items that have a tick of approval for low sugar, salt and fat would be tasteless unless they have added flavour enhancer. Flavour enhancers help to sell products that would otherwise taste stale or bland. That’s why it’s important to check the label when buying packaged foods. Some companies claim “no added MSG” but they have similar forms of MSG which are listed in Table 3.
TABLE 3
Keywords to look for when shopping for packaged foods:
Avoid: glutamate, monosodium glutamate, monopotassium glutamate, glutamic acid, calcium caseinate, gelatin, textured protein, hydrolyzed protein, HVP, yeast extract, yeast food, autolyzed yeast, yeast nutrient, HPP yeast extract, flavour enhancer.
These OFTEN contain MSG or create MSG during processing:
Avoid: “flavours”, “flavouring”, natural flavour, natural pork flavouring, bouillon, natural beef flavoring, stock, natural chicken flavoring, broth, malt flavoring, barley malt, malt extract, “seasonings”, carrageenan, soy sauce, soy sauce extract, soy protein, soy protein concentrate, soy protein isolate (protein powder), pectin, maltodextrin, whey protein, whey protein isolate, whey protein concentrate, anything protein fortified, protease, protease enzymes, enzymes, anything ultra-pasteurized, anything fermented. Also avoid ribonucleotide and numbers 620 to 635.
“What can I do about MSG sensitivity and eczema?”
Firstly, use a diet diary and record your symptoms. Eczema sufferers can benefit by avoiding all MSG products for a period of 12 weeks, or more. This helps to restore glutathione enzyme levels and boost liver health, and your body can become more resilient to MSG-containing foods. Then you can slowly reintroduce natural sources into your diet (you may need to keep avoiding artificial MSG in packaged foods). Eczema sufferers usually need to avoid a range of chemicals and allergy foods, not just MSG, in order to prevent eczema but avoiding MSG is a good start.
Clinical studies show MSG-induced liver damage can be reversed with vitamin E and vitamin B6. Changing your diet to one that is low in food chemicals and rich in nutritious, liver restorative foods and nutrients can reduce multiple chemical sensitivities and improve eczema symptoms. Stage 2 of The Eczema Diet shows you how to slowly increase your intake of natural MSG and other chemical-containing foods and stay eczema-free.
Printable FACT SHEET - Eczema and MSG Sensitivity
Fischer, K., 2014, 'Eczema and MSG Sensitivity' edited extract from The Eczema Diet, Second edition, Exisle Publishing. Photographer Rachael Scobie.
READ MORE: MSG Facts
MSG Facts
In 1908 a Japanese scientist discovered an active ingredient in seaweed could be used to greatly enhance the flavour of foods. Since then, the sodium salt monosodium glutamate (MSG, 621), isolated from glutamic acid in kombu, was used to flavour foods in Japan. The world-wide use of processed free glutamic acid soon exploded.
MSG is one of the most widely used food chemical additives in the world. Back in the 1960s, 262,000 tons of MSG was manufactured but today more than 800,000 tons are produced.
What is MSG?
MSG is a natural building block of proteins and when it’s not attached to protein it enhances the flavour of foods. However, consumption of MSG can cause a vast range of side-effects including eczema symptoms. The first medical reports on the adverse effects of MSG referred to it as “Chinese Restaurant Syndrome”.
MSG is a flavour enhancer that is natural (for example, it is naturally present in tomato) and it’s also artificial with a nature-identical versions added to foods such as savoury biscuits, canned soups, meat marinades and seasonings.
How MSG affects the brain
According to the American Nutrition Association, manufactured free glutamic acid and other forms of MSG, including hydrolyzed vegetable proteins, are added to processed foods to mask ‘off’ flavours. MSG basically makes the blandest and cheapest foods taste good. How does it work? Glutamic acid is a neurotransmitter that excites neurons in our brain (not just in our tongues). This electrical charging of neurons is what makes MSG-laden foods taste wonderful. The next time you eat MSG-rich foods, notice how you feel a few seconds afterwards. Unfortunately, our brains have many receptors for glutamic acid and some areas, such as the hypothalamus, do not have an impermeable blood-brain barrier, so free glutamic acid from food sources can enter the brain and sometimes damage the brain and kill neurons, according to the American Nutrition Association.
Low MSG doses can be problematic
American researchers tested how people react to MSG on an empty stomach (which is commonly when we eat). The subjects, who were mostly medical students and doctors, were fed soups with increasing doses of MSG and half of them reacted to low doses between 1.5 and 4 grams, and most of the remaining people reacted to doses between 5 and 12 grams, which are the amounts found in some packaged snack foods and takeaway meals. One 25 gram serve of protein powder contains about 4 gram of glutamic acid, which is a type of MSG.
Eczema, MSG and chemical sensitivity: the facts
- More than 90% of people with eczema have chemical sensitivities and 35% of people with eczema have adverse reactions to MSG (research by Loblay and Swain, RPA Hospital in Sydney).
- In animal studies, MSG ingestion caused liver inflammation and significantly increased the size of the liver, promoting liver damage.
- According to a Japanese study published in the Journal of Dermatology, consuming soy sauce*, fermented soybeans*, chocolate^, cheese^, coffee^ and yoghurt^ causes a worsening of eczema symptoms. After the avoidance of these foods for three months 100% of the participating eczema sufferers had reduced eczema symptoms. (*Products containing MSG, ^Products containing other problematic food chemicals)
- 36 healthy people were fed increasing doses of MSG and everyone suffered various adverse symptoms including burning sensations, irregular heartbeat and headaches. Some of the participants had adverse reactions to as little as 3 grams of MSG while others could tolerate up to 21 grams before they experienced unpleasant side-effects.
Fischer, K., 2014, ‘MSG Facts', www.eczemalife.com.au
READ MORE
What is the difference between eczema and dermatitis?
Products
At Eczema Life, we recommend nutritionist Karen Fischer's low food chemical program (The Eczema Detox) along with additive-free supplements for skin health and wellbeing. Click on the images to view more details: